Three Kit Houses In Fort Madison, Iowa: GVT Sharon, GVT Hudson, & Sears Strathmore

Authenticated Gordon-Van Tine Sharon model • 1935 • 1231 Avenue B, Fort Madison, Iowa

Today, I have three kit homes to show. This all started with this Gordon-Van Tine Sharon, in Fort Madison, Iowa.  I was just about to throw together a quick blog post about this authenticated GVT model that I found thanks to a mention of a real estate transfer, in an issue of the 1935 Des Moines Register, when I noticed that the house across the street looked to be a Gordon-Van Tine Hudson ! So, I thought I had better look around the neighborhood, and right down the street, I found what looks to be a Sears Strathmore. The catalog image to the right, is the Sharon as shown in the 1936 Gordon-Van Tine Book of Homes.   I was unfamiliar with the Sharon, but I know now, that it was first offered in the 1932 catalog, and appeared in the 1935 and 1936 catalogs, under the same name (1932 appears to be the year when Gordon-Van Tine changed the name of every house in their catalogs).

This home was built in 1935/36 by Dr. H. F. Noble.  A mention on page 45 of the June 2, 1935 edition of the Des Moines Register,  alerted me to a purchase through Gordon-Van Tine, and I was off to check Ancestry.com for the address of Dr. Noble.  

The Sharon model was offered as a one-floor, two-bedroom plan, or with a half story addition, containing two more bedrooms (Sharon B ).  The Lee County Iowa assessor's page for this house, describes it as having four bedrooms, so it looks like the Nobles opted for plan B.

GVT Sharon floor plan, as shown in the 1936 Book of Homes.

Dr. Harold F. Noble lived here with his wife, Frances, and their son, Harold D., and daughter Jeanette.  Harold Noble was only 32 when he bought this house. 

The Nobles in the 1940 U. S. census (Ancestry.com) Above them, at 1236, you see the Wallis family, who lived across the street in a Gordon-Van Tine Hudson.

The Nobles chose the reverse floor plan from what is shown in the catalog (GVT, like Sears, was happy to offer this option at no extra cost), so this last image (below), shows the side you don't see in the catalog image of the house.  I looks like they may have gotten a GVT garage at the same time!

1231 Avenue B, Fort Madison, Iowas • Authenticated Gordon-Van Tine Sharon

Gordon-Van Tine Hudson

As you can see from the snippet from the 1940 census, above, across the street from the Nobles, at 1236 Avenue B, Fort Madison, Iowa, lived the Wallis family: father Frank, mother Marie, son Frank, Jr., and daughter Carole.  The 1930 census puts them at this address, as does the 1931 City Directory, and the 1929 city directory has them elsewhere in town, and has no listing for a house yet at this address, so we can surmise that they are the first residents of the house.  The county assessor's records give a build date of 1929 for the house, so that fits in nicely, and must be accurate.  Their home looks to be a wonderfully kept-up Gordon-Van Tine Hudson:

1236 Avenue B., Fort Madison, Iowa • 1929 • Probable Gordon-Van Tine Hudson model

The Hudson should have four windows in the long side dormer, and our house does (by comparison, the smaller GVT Braddock has only 3 windows in that dormer).  We often see that side porch enclosed, as it is on the Fort Madison house.

The Hudson, from the 1929 Gordon-Van Tine catalog,
from our friends at AntiqueHome.org  

The images of the exterior and interior of this house in Fort Madison, are from the real estate listing at Realtor.com.

The left side of the GVT Hudson should have a side entry door, and two windows on the left side of the entry gable, as well as three windows in the big upper dormer.

The Hudson was on the cover of the 1929 and the 1931 catalogs, surrounded by beautiful, bright red. Here it is, shown on Daily Bungalow's Flickr album of the 1931 catalog:

The GVT Hudson has a TON of lookalikes.  This style house, in all kinds of variations, was offered by just about every U. S. kit company and plan-book company known to man in the late 1920s and 1930s (to see a Sears Cedars, for example, along with a long list of competing lookalikes by other companies, check out this blog post of mine).  Some have a chimney in front, and some don't. Obviously, the Hudson does, so that narrows things down. 

The Chimney and the Front Upper Window

If you see a front-chimney house of this style, the first thing to look at is the space on either side of the chimney... is there just one window there on the second floor, or is there a pair of windows, one on either side of the chimney? THAT is the first distinguishing feature of the two GVT models of this style: there is only ONE upper window on the front elevation.  Here is our Fort Madison house, as shown on the county assessor's page. Thank heavens they had a shot of the house without all of that foliage surrounding the chimney. Clearly, there is only one window!

Lee County Iowa tax assessor's photo of 1236 Avenue B.
Note the two windows on the side of the entry gable,
the side entry in the middle of this side of the house,
and the evenly-spaced three windows in the upper dormer on that side.

A very common lookalike to the GVT Hudson, is the 1926 C.L. Bowes Ankerton (offered in 1928 as the Home Builders Chenee).  On first glance at the front, they look like the same house. But, the Ankerton/Chenee has a little extra window up there to the left of the chimney:

(source)

Upon any kind of closer inspection, you'll note a number of other differences, but when you've just come across a house that you think might be the GVT Hudson, the window issue is the first thing to look for.

Another issue to notice, is the shape of the chimney.  Both the GVT Hudson (and the smaller Braddock), have a straight-sided, evenly-tapering chimney, with no bends or bottle shape (for lack of a better term).  This is helpful to distinguish it from the one lookalike that I know of that ALSO has only one window up there on the second floor: the CL Bowes Camanche (later known as the Home Builders Devore).  Notice that the Camanche/Devore has a sort of bottle shape to the chimney, so the tapering effect is different than on the GVT house. 

Image provided by our friends at Daily Bungalow: in the 1928 Home Builders catalog.

Gordon-VanTine Interior
From the realtor photos, we can see that the house at 1236 Avenue B has the layout of the Hudson's floor plan.  Notice, in this first double-image photo, how the fireplace and entry door and window fall just as they should, and,  though you can't see it in this first photo, the staircase is just there where it's indicated in this interior photo that is shown with this house, beginning with the 1932 catalog.

Living Room image from the online 1936 catalog.

And, here is the floor plan, as shown in the 1932, 1935, and 1936 catalogs (Hudson/Columbia).

The stair newel and balusters are exact likenesses to that shown in the 1936 catalog!

GVT Hudson = GVT Columbia
The links I included above, for the 1936 catalog, will not actually take you to a catalog page for the Hudson... they take you to the catalog page for the Columbia.  That's because, beginning in 1932, all of the GVT homes had their names changed (except, of course, for those introduced that year, like the Sharon ).  The Hudson, became the Columbia:

Though this is the new name of the Hudson model beginning in 1932, this image is actually from the online 1936 catalog.

GVT Braddock = GVT Raleigh
And, the smaller, slightly different GVT Braddock, had its name changed to the Raleigh, beginning in 1932:

From the 1936 catalog

Colorful Gordon-Van Tine Kitchens and Baths
The 1929-31 Gordon-Van Tine catalogs featured color pages showing off the beautiful color schemes GVT designers had planned for you, especially for your kitchens and baths (all of these images are from Daily Bungalow's online Flickr album of the GVT 1929-1930 catalog, available here):

This image shows Color Scheme A in the kitchen, and Color Scheme D in the bathroom. (source)

GVT Color Scheme A (source)

GVT Bathroom color scheme D (source)

(source)

(source)

GVT Kitchen color scheme B (source)

GVT Kitchen color scheme E (source)

So, it's possible that our GVT Hudson on Avenue B had these gorgeous colors originally.... or... there was still "Bathroom Color Scheme F: All panels, casework, and trim-- Ivory", and "Kitchen  Color Scheme C: All panels, casework, and trim -- Light Gray."

Sears Strathmore
And, finally, hidden away behind foliage that makes it hard to see this house well, down the street, at 1335 Avenue B, is what definitely looks to be a Sears Strathmore:

1335 Avenue B, Fort Madison, Iowa: Probable Sears Strathmore.
Lee County records give 1932 as the build year for this house (and that's the source of this image).

Many thanks to our friends at AntiqueHome.org / Daily Bungalow
This is from the 1932 Sears Modern Homes catalog

Everything looks correct for the Sears Strathmore • 1335 Avenue B, Fort Madison, Iowa

The only differences we see, are:
1-- The very small front window on the left elevation, which was for the front lavatory, is missing
2-- The side entry door is gone, making for a larger kitchen window.
3-- The Fort Madison house has a built-in, below-level garage.  My guess is that, with entry available through the garage (and no real space left to put a side porch for a side entry), the side door was eliminated.

Strathmore catalog image on the left; Fort Madison house on the right.

Sears Strathmore from the 1932 catalog at Archive.org (click to enlarge)

(source)

According to the Fort Madison City Directory, and U.S. Census records, it was the Wright family who lived here in this Sears Strathmore: Howard, his wife Margaret, and their son, Emerson.

The Howard Wright family in the 1940 U.S. Census (Ancestry.org)

According to the 1940 Census, and the 1939 City Directory, Howard Wright owned his own Car Dealership, called Wright Motor Company.

Howard Wright's profession, as listed on the 1940 U.S. Census

Though this 1939 City Directory shows Howard Wright running his own car dealership, previous city directories showed him to be working for the Sheaffer Pen Company, where Frank Wallis also worked. 

Sheaffer Pen and Pencil Company
One thing I learned from researching for this blog post, is that the famous Sheaffer Pen Company was begun in Fort Madison, Iowa, and remained there in full force until 2006, when its parent company, BIC, closed down the Fort Madison plant.  Both Frank Wallis (resident of the GVT Hudson ), and Howard Wright (resident of the Sears Strathmore ), worked for Sheaffer Pen Company in the early 1930s.

Here's Frank Wallis, in 1929 and 1931:

In 1929, Frank Wallis was an assembling manager at Sheaffer Pen

In 1931, Frank Wallis is shown as Department Manager at Sheaffer Pen

And, here is Howard Wright, in 1931, before moving to his Sears Strathmore, and opening his own car dealership:

Sheaffer Pen Company was begun by Iowan Walter Sheaffer, who developed and patented the system of a refillable fountain pen with a lever, in the 19-teens.  This invention was enormously popular, and led to a new standard in fountain pens around the world.  Sheaffer's main plant was in Fort Madison, Iowa, where he lived.

Source: SheafferTarga.com

The University of Iowa's Biographical Dictionary of Iowa has a very informative page about the development of the pens and mechanical pencils we have all come to know, that were first developed by Walter Sheaffer, and marketed at Sheaffer Pen and Pencil Company:

The "White Dot" lifetime pen with gold nib, was the gold-standard fountain pen developed by the Sheaffer Pen Company.
(source)

1937 Sheaffer Pen Advertisement (source)

The Sheaffer White Dot "Lifetime" fountain pen (source)

Sheaffer Pens:

• For information on the history and collectible value of Sheaffer pens, click here.
• To see many vintage Sheaffer pens, click here.
• To read more about the history of the Sheaffer Pen Company, click here, or here.
• To learn about the Sheaffer Pen Museum, in Fort Madison, Iowa, click here

Gordon-Van Tine

• For more information on Gordon-Van Tine, visit Dale Wolicki's www.GordonVanTine.com
• Visit the side bar Archives to see other Sears and Gordon-Van Tine homes 

Sears No. 124 in Tillamook, Oregon

Probable Sears No. 124 • 7050 Fairview Avenue, Tillamook, Oregon • 1913

Folks, we've got another Sears model No. 124 on the list! At least, we think it's one. This is number

Sears No. 124 as shown in Daily Bungalow's 1916 catalog. 

eleven on our national database of Sears houses in the U.S., and of those, only two (testimonial houses) are authenticated. But, this is such a unique home, that we're pretty confident when we find one. Even the "lookalike" model by Keith's magazine has easily identifiable differences, so we're usually pretty comfortable with the ID.  County tax site records tell us that this house was built in 1913, and that seems plausible:  Houses By Mail tells us that the No. 124 was offered as early as 1911, and continued in the catalogs through 1917, though we've seen it listed in the 1909.

I learned of this house through a comment left, early in February, on my blog post about the Sears No. 178 in Guthrie Center, Iowa.  The commenter mentioned that the 178 looked just like a house that she drove past every day on the way to work, in Tillamook, Oregon.  Thanks to that comment, I looked around Tillamook (using Google maps streetview), and, amazingly, came across this house.  (Hey, here's a request: if you know of a Sears house you'd like to tell us about, could you give us a street, and a nearby cross street? I had no idea where in Tillamook to look for this house.) Since it was on the commenter's way to work everyday, I decided to focus on a main road, first, and eventually found it. 

Sears No. 178 on the left (from my 1914 catalog); Sears No. 124 on the right, with its drastic dip front porch roof.

The No. 178 and the No. 124 are sisters. Or cousins. Or half-siblings. Or something :) The No. 178 is a full two stories, including front windows on the upper rooms -- one being a bay window, to top the bay window on the first floor front -- and the No. 124 is two full stories, but with an overhanging front porch roof that dips very low in the front, obscuring the upper front windows that the catalog's floor plan says are there.  You can't see them at all, if they are there. Take a look at this image:

You can see from these two front elevation views, that there is much more upper front to see, on the No. 178.  If you look at the floor plans for the two models, next to each other, you see very little difference in the main rooms at all... just the upstairs front right bedroom having a bay window on the 178, that is absent from the No. 124:

Sears No. 178 and No. 124 floor plans.

The No. 124 vs Keith's Magazine's Lookalike

The only lookalike model to the No. 124 that we're aware of, is a plan-only model (not available as a kit) put out early in the 1900s by Keith's Magazine.  The two are remarkably similar, but the side view of our Tillamook house shows clearly that it contains features only seen on the Sears model, and not on Keith's: two full-size upper windows on the upper left elevation, and a small square opening in the side of the porch roof overhang:

The dormers are obviously different, too, but there is another view of this Keith's model,
with a dormer similar to the Sears dormer.

Unfortunately, I don't have any interior photos to show you, of the Tillamook house, but here's a view of the other side of the house (all house views are thanks to Google maps streetview):

However, a Sears No. 124 in Rensselaer, New York came up for sale in the past few years, and we were treated to some beautiful interior photos (click to enlarge):

Here is the Trulia listing for this house.

Gleaming, gorgeous floors and woodwork.

Here's the front bay window.

Our Western U.S. Sears Houses
What is exciting about locating this Tillamook, Oregon Sears house, is that it is so far west in the United States.  We don't believe that there are many Sears homes west of the central part of the U.S. Those we've been able to find are few and far between.  This No. 124 in Tillamook is, in fact, the most far west we have found any Sears house, except for one that we know of in Alaska.  So, if you happen upon this blog, and you know of any Sears houses in our western U.S. states, please leave a comment (with a street and nearby cross street, or, even better, an address).  Don't worry that you might be mistaken -- we'd rather investigate, and rule out, than not know of a Sears house just waiting to be found!

I'll leave you with a look at the very impressive map that researcher Andrew Mutch (Kit House Hunters) put together for us, with all of the over 6,500 Sears homes that we've located to date:

Our actual map is interactive, so we can zoom in and out, and click to get an address.  This is just a screenshot.

To see the No. 178 that I located in Guthrie Center, Iowa (including interior photos from a real estate listing), go here.